Top 5 Picks

Best Cooler Reviews

YETI Tundra 45 Cooler

Average Rating (4.8)

The YETI Tundra 45 is a durable, bear-resistant cooler designed for outdoor enthusiasts. It features rotomolded construction, heavy-duty rubber latches, and a freezer-quality gasket to keep ice frozen for days. Its size is perfect for weekend trips, and it includes tie-down points and non-slip feet.

Users praise the YETI Tundra 45 for its exceptional ice retention and rugged build quality, making it ideal for extended outdoor use. Many appreciate the sturdy latches and the cooler's ability to withstand rough handling without damage. Some reviewers mention the weight when empty but agree that the performance justifies it.

Pros

Excellent ice retention
Durable, rotomolded construction
Bear-resistant design
Heavy-duty rubber latches
Non-slip feet and tie-down points

Cons

Heavy when empty
Higher price point
Limited color options
No built-in drain plug
Can be bulky for small vehicles

Read full review →

RTIC 65 Quart Hard Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.7)

The RTIC 65 Quart Hard Cooler is a high-performance cooler with thick insulation and a rugged design. It offers excellent ice retention, a freezer-quality gasket, and heavy-duty latches. The cooler is designed for serious outdoor use and comes with a lifetime warranty.

Users consistently praise the RTIC 65 for its ice retention and durability, comparing it favorably to more expensive brands. The heavy-duty latches and sturdy build are frequently mentioned. Some note that the cooler is heavy when empty but accept this as a trade-off for performance.

Pros

Superior ice retention
Rugged, durable construction
Heavy-duty latches
Freezer-quality gasket
Lifetime warranty

Cons

Heavy when empty
Bulky size
Higher price than budget coolers
Limited color options
No built-in cup holders

Read full review →

Pelican Elite 20 Quart Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.6)

The Pelican Elite 20 Quart Cooler is a compact, high-quality cooler with extreme ice retention capabilities. It features a press-and-pull latching system, antimicrobial liner, and a non-slip base. This cooler is ideal for day trips and small groups.

Reviewers love the Pelican Elite 20 for its compact size combined with excellent ice retention. The antimicrobial liner is appreciated for keeping the cooler fresh. Some users mention the price is higher than other small coolers but feel the quality justifies it.

Pros

Excellent ice retention
Compact and portable
Press-and-pull latching system
Antimicrobial liner
Non-slip base

Cons

Higher price for size
Smaller capacity
No drain plug
Limited color options
Lid can be stiff initially

Read full review →

Igloo BMX 52 Quart Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.5)

The Igloo BMX 52 Quart Cooler offers a balance of affordability and performance with its insulated walls and a large capacity. It features a sturdy handle, a built-in cup holder, and a drain plug for easy cleaning. This cooler is suitable for family outings and sports events.

Reviewers highlight the Igloo BMX's value for money, noting that it keeps ice frozen for a reasonable amount of time. The built-in cup holders and easy-to-carry handle are frequently mentioned as convenient features. Some users note that the lid seal could be tighter for improved ice retention.

Pros

Affordable price
Large 52-quart capacity
Built-in cup holders
Easy to carry with sturdy handle
Drain plug for easy cleaning

Cons

Ice retention not as long as premium coolers
Lid seal could be improved
Plastic latches less durable
Heavier than some competitors
Limited color choices

Read full review →

Coleman Xtreme 5 Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.3)

The Coleman Xtreme 5 is a compact cooler designed for day trips and picnics. It features insulation that keeps ice for up to 5 days in temperatures up to 90°F. The cooler is lightweight, has a carry handle, and is available in multiple colors.

Customers appreciate the Coleman Xtreme 5 for its portability and decent ice retention for its size. It's often recommended for short trips and casual use. Some users mention that the lid hinges could be sturdier, but overall it offers good value for the price.

Pros

Lightweight and portable
Keeps ice up to 5 days
Multiple color options
Affordable
Compact size fits easily in vehicles

Cons

Lid hinges can be fragile
Smaller capacity
Not suitable for extended trips
Plastic construction less durable
No drain plug

Read full review →