Top 5 Picks

Best Ice Chest Reviews

YETI Tundra 45 Cooler

Average Rating (4.8)

The YETI Tundra 45 is a durable, bear-resistant ice chest designed for long-lasting ice retention and rugged outdoor use. It features rotomolded construction, heavy-duty rubber latches, and a non-slip base.

Users praise the YETI Tundra 45 for its exceptional ice retention and rugged build quality, making it ideal for extended trips. Many appreciate its bear-resistant design and sturdy latches that hold up well in rough conditions. Some mention the cooler is heavier than others but agree the durability and performance justify the weight.

Pros

Excellent ice retention
Bear-resistant design
Durable rotomolded construction
Heavy-duty rubber latches
Non-slip base

Cons

Heavier than many competitors
Higher price point
Limited color options
No built-in drain plug
Handles can be uncomfortable when fully loaded

Read full review →

RTIC 65 Quart Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.7)

The RTIC 65 Quart Cooler is a high-capacity, durable ice chest designed for extended outdoor use. It features rotomolded construction, thick insulation, and heavy-duty latches for superior ice retention.

Users highlight the RTIC 65 for its excellent ice retention and large capacity, making it perfect for group outings. The cooler's sturdy build and secure latches receive positive feedback, though some mention it is quite heavy when fully loaded.

Pros

Large capacity
Excellent ice retention
Durable rotomolded construction
Heavy-duty latches
Non-slip feet

Cons

Heavy when full
Higher price point
Limited color options
No built-in bottle opener
Handles can be hard on hands

Read full review →

Pelican Elite 20 Quart Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.6)

The Pelican Elite 20 Quart Cooler is a compact, rugged ice chest with excellent ice retention and a lifetime guarantee. It features a press-and-pull latch system and antimicrobial liner for easy cleaning.

Reviewers love the Pelican Elite 20 for its compact size and impressive ice retention. The antimicrobial liner and easy-to-use latch system are frequently praised. Some users find it smaller than expected but perfect for day trips or personal use.

Pros

Compact and portable
Excellent ice retention
Press-and-pull latch system
Antimicrobial liner
Lifetime guarantee

Cons

Smaller capacity
Higher price for size
No cup holders
Heavier than other small coolers
Limited color options

Read full review →

Igloo BMX 52 Quart Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.5)

The Igloo BMX 52 Quart Cooler offers a balance of affordability and performance with a durable design, good ice retention, and convenient features like a built-in bottle opener and cup holders.

Reviewers like the Igloo BMX for its value and solid ice retention for day trips. The built-in bottle opener and cup holders are frequently mentioned as handy features. Some users note it is bulkier than other models but appreciate the sturdy handles and overall build quality.

Pros

Affordable price
Good ice retention for the price
Built-in bottle opener
Cup holders on the lid
Sturdy handles

Cons

Bulkier design
Lid can be hard to close tightly
Ice retention not as long as premium models
Plastic latches less durable
No drain plug

Read full review →

Coleman Xtreme 5 Cooler

Google Search

Average Rating (4.3)

The Coleman Xtreme 5 Cooler is a budget-friendly option designed for keeping ice cold for up to 5 days. It features thick insulation, a sturdy build, and a convenient carry handle.

Customers appreciate the Coleman Xtreme 5 for its affordability and decent ice retention, especially for short camping trips. Many find it lightweight and easy to carry, though some mention the lid and latches feel less robust compared to higher-end models.

Pros

Affordable
Keeps ice cold up to 5 days
Lightweight and portable
Thick insulation
Easy to carry handle

Cons

Lid and latches less durable
Not bear-resistant
No drain plug
Plastic construction can feel cheap
Limited color options

Read full review →